The statute of limitations is a strict deadline for filing lawsuits. Once it expires, the case is over—permanently. But what happens when a process server makes a mistake?
Improper service can delay a lawsuit, waste valuable time, and even cause the statute of limitations to run out—effectively killing the case. Here’s how it happens and what defendants can do to challenge it.
1. If the Plaintiff Misses the Deadline, the Case Is Over
Most lawsuits must be filed and properly served within a set period. Failure to do so results in permanent dismissal.
Common Statute of Limitations for Civil Cases:
Personal Injury: 2-3 years (varies by state)
Debt Collection: 3-6 years
Breach of Contract: 4-6 years
Property Disputes: 5-10 years
If improper service causes a missed deadline:
The plaintiff loses the right to sue—forever.
The defendant can file a motion to dismiss with prejudice (meaning it cannot be refiled).
Once the statute runs out, no amount of fixing service can revive the case.
2. Delayed Service Can Push the Case Past the Statute of Limitations
Many states require service to be completed within a certain timeframe after filing the lawsuit.
Common Deadlines for Service After Filing:
30-120 days in most states
90 days for federal cases
If improper service causes delays:
The plaintiff may need to file a motion to extend service (courts do not always approve it).
If denied, the case is dismissed, and the statute of limitations may expire.
A careless process server can waste crucial time—costing the plaintiff their case.
3. A Defendant Can Challenge Service & Stall Until the Statute Runs Out
If a defendant realizes service was improper, they can use legal strategies to delay the case until the statute of limitations expires.
Common Delay Tactics:
Filing a Motion to Quash Service – Forces the plaintiff to redo service, eating up time.
Challenging Every Service Attempt – Repeated service failures run down the clock.
Avoiding Process Servers – If a defendant dodges service long enough, the statute may expire.
A defendant who understands the deadline can turn improper service into a free pass out of the lawsuit.
4. Courts May Refuse to Grant Extensions for Improper Service
Plaintiffs can request an extension, but judges don’t always allow it.
Reasons Courts Deny Extensions:
The plaintiff had enough time but failed to act.
The process server was negligent or unqualified.
The defendant was unfairly delayed in their ability to respond.
If the judge denies an extension, the case is permanently dismissed.
5. Fraudulent or False Service Can Invalidate the Case
If a process server lies about completing service and the statute of limitations expires, the plaintiff has no time left to fix it.
Common Fraudulent Service Tactics:
Falsifying an affidavit of service (perjury)
Serving the wrong person but claiming it was the defendant
Fabricating an entire service attempt to avoid redoing it
Consequences for the Plaintiff:
The defendant can file a motion to dismiss due to improper service.
If the statute has expired, the plaintiff is out of time.
The case is permanently dismissed with no option to refile.
A dishonest process server can ruin an entire lawsuit with one false affidavit.
6. Some States Allow “Relation Back” If Improper Service Is Fixed
In certain cases, courts may allow service to be corrected if the plaintiff acts quickly.
What Is "Relation Back"?
It allows a lawsuit to continue even if service was initially incorrect, as long as it is properly completed later.
The plaintiff must prove good faith and that they did not deliberately delay service.
The defendant must not be unfairly harmed by the delay.
Not all states allow this—some dismiss cases permanently once the statute runs out.
How to Prevent Improper Service from Killing a Lawsuit
Both plaintiffs and process servers must act swiftly and follow the law to avoid losing cases due to service mistakes.
For Plaintiffs:
Hire a professional, licensed process server.
Track service attempts with GPS, video, or sworn statements.
Verify state service laws to avoid technical errors.
Request an extension BEFORE the deadline expires.
For Defendants Challenging Improper Service:
Document all service attempts (security cameras, work records, travel logs).
File a Motion to Quash if service was incorrect.
Use legal delays to let the statute of limitations expire.
When service is done correctly, the case moves forward. If not, the lawsuit could disappear forever.
Final Takeaway: Bad Service Can Destroy a Case Before It Even Starts
The statute of limitations is the ultimate deadline—if improper service causes delays, the case can be permanently dismissed.
Key Takeaways:
Missed deadlines = Case dismissed forever.
Delayed service = The defendant can run out the clock.
Fraudulent service = No way to fix it once the statute expires.
Courts may refuse to extend the deadline.
Explore These Related Topics:
🔹 Most Common Reasons for Improper Service and How It Can Ruin a Case
Learn about common service mistakes and how they can weaken a legal claim.
🔹 How Improper Service Can Lead to the Dismissal of a Case
Discover why courts may throw out cases due to faulty service.
🔹 How to Prove Improper Service and Challenge It in Court
Find out how to contest improper service and protect your legal rights.
🔹 The Financial Cost of Improper Service: Avoid Costly Mistakes
See how improper service can lead to unnecessary legal fees and financial setbacks.
Testimonials from Our Clients
What Clients Say About Our People-First Approach
Want service done right the first time?
Call The Process Server (TPS). We don’t miss deadlines—we deliver legally, efficiently, and without excuses.
"*" indicates required fields
Ready to Talk?
Journey with The Process Server (TPS) and experience the simplicity and comprehensiveness of expert legal support by TPS.
We're here to assist you with any legal support services you may require.
We're here to assist you with any legal support services you may require. Although our main office is located in Phoenix, we have dedicated local teams to handle all location-specific tasks efficiently. Here's how you can get in touch with us.
The Process Server
13416 North 32nd Street #110F, Phoenix, Arizona 85032, United States
Phone: +1 (602) 675-2333
Email: service@processserver.io
For further details, please refer to the Justice Courts Case Search.