Yes! In many cases, you can negotiate with your landlord to have an eviction removed from your record—especially if you take the right approach. While Arizona does not automatically erase eviction records, landlords and property managers do have the power to withdraw or modify eviction filings in certain situations.
If you’re willing to pay off past debts, settle disputes, or reach a fair agreement, your landlord may agree to remove or amend your eviction record—helping you secure better rental opportunities in the future.
1. Understand What Can Be Removed
Before negotiating, figure out what type of eviction record you have.
Types of Eviction Records That Can Be Negotiated:
Court-Filed Evictions – If your landlord filed an eviction lawsuit (Forcible Detainer) in Arizona courts, you may be able to get the case dismissed, withdrawn, or vacated by negotiating.
Tenant Screening Reports – Some evictions don’t appear in court records but are reported to rental databases like CoreLogic or Experian RentBureau—still affecting your ability to rent.
Collection Accounts – If unpaid rent was sent to collections, you may be able to negotiate a pay-for-deletion agreement to remove it from your credit report.
If your eviction resulted in a court judgment or collections, negotiating with your landlord is often the best way to remove it.
2. The Best Times to Negotiate Eviction Removal
Timing is everything. Your landlord may be more willing to negotiate in certain situations.
Ideal Times to Negotiate Eviction Removal:
Before an eviction lawsuit is finalized – If you catch it early, the landlord may agree to dismiss the case before it’s permanently recorded.
After paying off rental debts – Landlords are more likely to help remove negative records if their financial losses are covered.
When applying for a new rental – Some landlords will remove an old eviction if you’re applying for another one of their properties.
If the eviction resulted from special circumstances – Medical emergencies, job loss, or other hardships may make a landlord more sympathetic.
The earlier you negotiate, the better your chances of getting an eviction removed.
3. How to Approach Your Landlord for Eviction Removal
Your landlord doesn’t have to remove an eviction—but if you make a compelling case, they may agree.
How to Start the Conversation:
Be respectful and professional – Approach it like a business negotiation.
Acknowledge past issues and take responsibility – Show that you understand why the eviction happened and that you’ve taken steps to fix it.
Offer something in return – Most landlords will only agree to remove an eviction if they receive payment, a settlement, or some other benefit.
Get everything in writing – Always document agreements to avoid misunderstandings.
Being honest, respectful, and willing to compromise increases your chances of success.
4. What Can You Offer in Exchange for Eviction Removal?
Most landlords won’t remove an eviction out of goodwill—you need to offer something in return.
Best Negotiation Tactics:
Pay off past-due rent – Offer to settle any outstanding balance in exchange for eviction removal.
Set up a payment plan – If you can’t pay in full, a structured plan may work.
Offer additional fees – Some landlords accept a small “goodwill” payment to process an eviction removal request.
Agree to a positive rental reference – If you were a good tenant aside from the eviction, they may agree to clear your record in exchange for helping their reputation.
Sign a new lease – If you’re willing to rent from them again, they might be open to wiping out past records.
Landlords care about getting paid—resolve unpaid debts, and they’re more likely to help you.
5. Legal Ways a Landlord Can Remove an Eviction
If a landlord agrees to remove an eviction, they can do it legally in several ways.
Legal Eviction Removal Methods:
Filing a Motion to Vacate or Dismiss the Eviction Case – If the eviction was filed in court, the landlord can request that the case be dismissed or vacated.
Withdrawing the Eviction Filing – Some landlords can request court records be sealed or withdrawn if both parties agree.
Updating Tenant Screening Databases – Landlords can contact rental reporting agencies to remove an eviction from their records.
Requesting a Pay-for-Deletion with Collections – If past-due rent was sent to collections, landlords can negotiate a removal once paid.
If a landlord refuses to remove the eviction, you may be able to petition the court to set aside the judgment.
6. What If the Landlord Refuses to Negotiate?
Not all landlords will agree to remove an eviction—but you still have options.
What to Do If Your Landlord Won’t Help:
File a Motion to Set Aside the Judgment – If you’ve paid off your debts or the eviction was unfair, you can ask the court to remove it.
Dispute Errors in Tenant Screening Reports – If an eviction appears incorrectly, you can dispute it with CoreLogic, Experian RentBureau, and TransUnion SmartMove.
Wait for the Eviction to Expire – Evictions stay on your record for up to seven years but lose impact over time.
If your landlord won’t remove the eviction, legal and credit dispute options may still help.
Final Takeaway: Can You Negotiate Eviction Removal? Yes, But It Takes Strategy
Landlords aren’t required to remove an eviction, but many will if you offer a fair settlement.
Best Ways to Negotiate:
Offer to pay off past rent or damages.
Set up a payment plan or goodwill fee.
Get agreements in writing before making payments.
Request that the eviction be vacated, dismissed, or removed from screening reports.
If a Landlord Refuses:
File a Motion to Set Aside the judgment.
Dispute the eviction with tenant screening agencies.
Rebuild rental history with private landlords.
The key to success? Take action, communicate professionally, and be willing to offer something in return.
Testimonials from Our Clients
What Clients Say About Our People-First Approach
Take the Next Step with The Process Server
Connect with us and let our experts help you tackle any legal challenge effortlessly. Start your journey to effective solutions today. Your legal concerns are our priority.
"*" indicates required fields
Ready to Talk?
Journey with The Process Server (TPS) and experience the simplicity and comprehensiveness of expert legal support by TPS.
We're here to assist you with any legal support services you may require.
We're here to assist you with any legal support services you may require. Although our main office is located in Phoenix, we have dedicated local teams to handle all location-specific tasks efficiently. Here's how you can get in touch with us.
The Process Server
13416 North 32nd Street #110F, Phoenix, Arizona 85032, United States
Phone: +1 (602) 675-2333
Email: [email protected]
For further details, please refer to the Justice Courts Case Search.